How to avoid defmulti being defonce with the REPL session?

(note: using Cider)
I use defmulti and defmethod in my code, eval-buffer, and test them. They have an error, so I rewrite them (change them to receive a map instead of sequential args). However, eval-buffer won’t update the definition; only restarting the repl session seems to capture my changes. Is there a way to cause macros like defmulti to reload without restarting my repl?

defmulti defaults to defonce semantics. Add a def before the defmulti declaration to get def semantics instead:

(def foo nil)
(defmulti foo (fn [n m] n))
(defmethod foo :default [n m] (prn [:n n]))
1 Like

Does this work with all macros?

defmulti is indeed a macro but so far as I can see whether or not it’s implemented as a macro is not relevant to its reevaluation behavior.

Indeed, defmulti does this because otherwise reevaluating the defmulti would invalidate all the corresponding defmethods.

1 Like

Oh, interesting. I always thought it was an issue because of class generation. I’m not sure I totally follow the logic, like, what scenario would it be a problem? Since namespaces are loaded once only anyways.

Perhaps could help? It mentions defmulti so I suppose it works with that.

What about clojurescript where everything is reloaded when a file changes? Any tips on handling this? I vaguely remember seeing something like:

(def cool-multi nil)
(defmethod cool-multi ,,,)

But I’m not sure if that was the right thing to do or not.

This topic was automatically closed 182 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.